Madras High Court: OBC Status Is Not Permanent, Admits Challenge to Backward Class Lists
On 12 November 2026, a Division Bench of the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court (Justices G.R. Swaminathan and M.D. Sumathi) admitted a writ petition, G. Kodeeswaran v. State of Tamil Nadu. Admitting a petition means the court found it serious enough to hear in full; it is not a final decision.
The petition challenges entries in Schedule I of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016, which lists the state's Backward Classes (BC) and Most Backward Classes (MBC). It questions:
the inclusion of Christian Nadars, Christian Shanars and Christian Gramanis in the BC list;
MBC status for converts to Christianity from the Meenavar, Parvatharajakulam, Pattanavar, Sembadavar and Mukkuvar communities;
the inclusion of members of the Church of South India (CSI). The petitioner argued that even a person from a forward caste could get BC status by joining the CSI. The court said that if this is true, a serious rethink is needed.
The petitioner says these entries were made without objective data on social and educational backwardness, as required under Article 16(4). He points out that Tamil Nadu's Second Backward Classes Commission (J.A. Ambashankar, report 1985) had found Christian converts from backward classes ineligible, yet a government order of 24 February 1986 extended benefits to them.
The court said there is nothing permanent about a community's OBC status: a clear case must be made both for inclusion and for retention in the list. Enjoying reservation for a long time does not by itself prove that the original inclusion was valid. When an entry is challenged, the State must justify it.
Notice was issued to the Tamil Nadu government and the Tamil Nadu Backward Classes Commission, returnable in eight weeks. The court also added the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission (TNPSC) as a respondent on its own, because recruitment is going on.
Periodic Revision of Backward Classes Lists: Why OBC Status Is Not Permanent
In India, communities that are socially and educationally backward are placed on an official list of Backward Classes (commonly called Other Backward Classes or OBCs). People from these communities get reservation in government jobs and in admission to colleges. But backwardness is not meant to be a permanent label. As a community makes progress, it may no longer need help, while some other group may be left behind. Periodic revision means checking these lists from time to time: adding communities that are truly backward, and removing those that have moved ahead.
The Madras High Court applied this idea to Tamil Nadu's own list. It said a community's place on the BC or MBC list is not permanent: when an entry is challenged, the State must show current, objective data that the group is still backward. The Court found serious doubts because the state's own 1985 commission had advised against including Christian converts from backward classes.
Religious Conversion and Reservation: SC, ST and OBC Status
Some groups in India get reservation because they faced deep social disadvantage. When a person changes religion, a key question is whether that person keeps the reserved status. The answer is different for each group. Scheduled Caste (SC) status is tied to religion, Scheduled Tribe (ST) status is not, and OBC status depends on the community, not the religion.
The new petition asks whether people who convert to Christianity can keep or gain BC or MBC status. It also asks whether joining a church, like the CSI, can by itself give a person backward class status. The court will now examine these questions under the rules on conversion and reservation.
Articles 15(4) and 16(4): Reservation for Backward Classes
Articles 15 and 16 are part of the Right to Equality in Part III of the Constitution. Article 15(4) lets the State make special provisions, such as reserved college seats, for socially and educationally backward classes, SCs and STs. Article 16(4) lets the State reserve government posts for any backward class of citizens that is not adequately represented in the State's services. These clauses are how the Constitution allows "unequal treatment to make people equal".
The petitioner argues that the Christian communities in Tamil Nadu's BC and MBC lists were added without the data on backwardness and representation that Article 16(4) needs. The High Court's order puts that question to the State.
- Case: G. Kodeeswaran v. State of Tamil Nadu, WP(MD) 32363/2026, admitted 12 November 2026
- Bench: Justices G.R. Swaminathan and M.D. Sumathi, Madurai Bench, Madras High Court
- Law challenged: Schedule I, Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016
- Government orders cited: G.O.Ms. No. 2029 (5 August 1983) included Christian Nadars, Shanars and Gramanis; G.O.Ms. No. 558 (24 February 1986) included converts from Hindu backward class communities
- TN First BC Commission: A.N. Sattanathan (report 1970); Second: J.A. Ambashankar (report 1985)
- Notice returnable in 8 weeks; TNPSC added as respondent by the court on its own motion
- Central OBC quota: 27%; Tamil Nadu total reservation: 69%
- NCBC: constitutional body under Article 338B (102nd Amendment, 2018); states' own lists under Article 342A(3) (105th Amendment, 2021)