Judicial Misconduct and the Justice Karnan Case: Why India Needs Something Between Silence and Removal
A recent analysis looked back at the case of Justice C.S. Karnan, which first brought the problem of misconduct by higher court judges into public debate.
In 2017, Justice Karnan, then a sitting judge of the Calcutta High Court, was found guilty of contempt of court by a seven-judge bench of the Supreme Court headed by the Chief Justice of India. On May 9, 2017, he was sentenced to six months in jail. He was the first sitting High Court judge to be sentenced to jail for contempt.
Before this, he had made public allegations against several judges and had issued "orders" against Supreme Court judges, including one "sentencing" them. He retired on June 12, 2017 and was arrested on June 20, 2017 in Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu.
The case raised two big questions. First, whether India's system for selecting and appointing judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts needs to be revisited. Second, whether there should be a way to deal with judicial misconduct other than full removal by Parliament, which is very hard to use.
The only constitutional way to remove a higher court judge is a removal motion passed by a special majority in both Houses of Parliament. Below that, there is only the judiciary's own informal "in-house procedure".
In-House Procedure and Judicial Accountability Mechanisms
The in-house procedure is a system created by the Supreme Court itself to look into complaints against judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts. It is not written in the Constitution or in any law passed by Parliament. It works like an internal check: senior judges first examine a complaint quietly, and if they find serious wrongdoing, they can advise the judge to resign or report the matter to the government so that Parliament can begin removal. It cannot remove a judge by itself.
The Karnan case showed that India has no formal disciplinary tool between doing nothing and full removal by Parliament. The in-house procedure is the only middle step, and its limits (secrecy, no power to punish) are exactly why experts keep calling for an alternative to the removal process.
Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968
The Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 is the law that sets out, step by step, how Parliament investigates a complaint against a judge of the Supreme Court or a High Court before deciding whether to remove the judge. The Constitution says a judge can be removed only for "proved misbehaviour or incapacity", and this Act explains how that proof is to be gathered. It was made under Article 124(5) of the Constitution.
This difficult, all-or-nothing process is the only formal way to remove a judge. Its difficulty is the reason experts say India needs a lighter alternative for misconduct like that seen in the Karnan case.
Contempt of Court: Constitutional and Statutory Framework
Contempt of court means disobeying a court's order or disrespecting a court in a way that harms the justice system. The Supreme Court (Article 129) and the High Courts (Article 215) are "courts of record" and have the power to punish for contempt of themselves. The details are set out in the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.
The Supreme Court used its contempt power against Justice Karnan because no other disciplinary tool could act quickly against a sitting High Court judge. Critics argued that contempt was being used to fill a gap that a proper misconduct procedure should have filled.
Collegium System and Judicial Appointments
The collegium system is the way judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts are chosen in India. A small group of the senior-most judges, called the collegium, recommends names, and the government appoints them through the President. This system is not written in the Constitution; it was created by Supreme Court judgments.
One lesson drawn from the Karnan case is that the selection of judges itself needs a fresh look, so that concerns about a candidate's conduct are examined properly before appointment, not only after problems appear.
- Justice C.S. Karnan: sentenced to six months' jail for contempt on May 9, 2017, by a seven-judge Supreme Court bench; retired June 12, 2017; arrested June 20, 2017 in Coimbatore.
- He was the first sitting High Court judge sentenced to jail for contempt of court.
- Removal of judges: Article 124(4) (Supreme Court) and Article 218 (High Courts); special majority in both Houses in the same session.
- Removal motion notice: at least 100 Lok Sabha or 50 Rajya Sabha members (Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968).
- No Supreme Court or High Court judge has ever been removed by Parliament.
- In-house procedure adopted by the Supreme Court's Full Court on December 15, 1999.
- Contempt of Courts Act, 1971: maximum punishment of six months' simple imprisonment or ₹2,000 fine, or both.