In-House Procedure and Judicial Accountability Mechanisms
The in-house procedure is a system created by the Supreme Court itself to look into complaints against judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts. It is not written in the Constitution or in any law passed by Parliament. It works like an internal check: senior judges first examine a complaint quietly, and if they find serious wrongdoing, they can advise the judge to resign or report the matter to the government so that Parliament can begin removal. It cannot remove a judge by itself.
Why does it exist?
The Constitution protects higher court judges very strongly, so that no government can threaten or punish them for giving honest judgments. A judge of the Supreme Court or a High Court can be removed only by Parliament, through a long and difficult process (often loosely called "impeachment"). But many kinds of wrong behaviour are not serious enough for removal, or cannot easily be proved in Parliament.
Examples are rude conduct, delays, or doubtful dealings with lawyers. The Constitution says nothing about any punishment smaller than removal. So there was a gap: either a judge was removed, or nothing happened at all. The in-house procedure was created to fill this gap.
Where did it come from?
- 1995: In C. Ravichandran Iyer v. Justice A.M. Bhattacharjee, the Supreme Court said there was a gap between "bad conduct" and the very high bar of "proved misbehaviour" needed for removal. It suggested that the judiciary create its own procedure to deal with such conduct.
- May 7, 1997: A Full Court meeting of the Supreme Court (a meeting of all its judges) adopted two resolutions. One was the Restatement of Values of Judicial Life, a code of conduct for judges. The other called for an in-house procedure to take remedial action against judges who do not follow these values.
- December 15, 1999: After a committee of judges prepared the detailed steps, the Full Court adopted the in-house procedure. It was kept confidential for years and was made public only in 2014.
How does it work, step by step?
Take a complaint against a High Court judge:
- The complaint reaches the Chief Justice of that High Court or the Chief Justice of India (CJI).
- The High Court Chief Justice looks at it first. If it seems serious, he or she asks the judge for a reply and sends comments to the CJI.
- The CJI decides whether the complaint is baseless or needs a deeper inquiry.
- If a deeper inquiry is needed, the CJI sets up a three-member committee. For a High Court judge, it has two Chief Justices of other High Courts and one High Court judge. For a High Court Chief Justice, it has one Supreme Court judge and two Chief Justices of other High Courts. For a Supreme Court judge, it has three Supreme Court judges.
- The committee holds a fact-finding inquiry. The judge can appear and explain his or her side. It is not a trial in court.
- The committee reports to the CJI. It can find that there is no substance in the complaint, that the misconduct is not serious enough for removal, or that it is serious enough for removal.
- If it is not serious enough for removal, the CJI can advise the judge. If it is serious enough, the CJI asks the judge to resign or take voluntary retirement.
- If the judge refuses, the CJI can ask that no judicial work be given to the judge, and can send the committee's report to the President and the Prime Minister, so that the removal process in Parliament can begin.
A simple way to picture it: think of a school where only the school board can expel a teacher. The in-house procedure is like the principal and two senior teachers quietly inquiring first, advising the teacher to leave if things are bad, and writing to the board if the teacher refuses.
What have the courts said about it?
- Indira Jaising v. Registrar General, Supreme Court of India (2003): The Supreme Court refused to make an in-house inquiry report public, saying the procedure is confidential and meant only for the CJI's own satisfaction.
- Additional District and Sessions Judge 'X' v. Registrar General, High Court of Madhya Pradesh (2014): The Court accepted the in-house procedure as valid and explained how it should be followed.
- Yashwant Varma v. Union of India (August 7, 2025): The Court rejected a High Court judge's challenge to the procedure. It held that the 1999 Full Court resolution has full legal backing, and that the in-house inquiry is only a preliminary fact-finding process, not a removal mechanism. Sending the report to the President and Prime Minister does not take away Parliament's own power to decide.
Indian examples
- In 2025, after a large amount of burnt cash was reported at the official residence of a Delhi High Court judge, Justice Yashwant Varma, the CJI set up a three-member in-house committee. It found the matter serious and the CJI forwarded its report to the President and the Prime Minister. Parliament then started the statutory process: the Lok Sabha Speaker set up a committee under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 in August 2025. Justice Varma resigned in April 2026, and the statutory committee's report, submitted in May 2026, found the charges proved.
- The in-house procedure was not used against Justice Karnan. Instead, the Supreme Court used its contempt power, which is a different tool meant to protect the authority of courts, not a disciplinary process for judges.
Commonly confused concepts
- In-house procedure vs removal under Article 124(4): The in-house procedure is an internal judicial process created by a Supreme Court resolution; it can only advise, withdraw work or recommend. Removal is a constitutional process done by Parliament, and it is the only way to actually remove a judge.
- In-house committee vs Judges (Inquiry) Act committee: The in-house committee is set up by the CJI and its report goes to the CJI. The committee under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 is set up by the Lok Sabha Speaker or the Rajya Sabha Chairman after a removal motion is admitted, and its report goes to Parliament.
- In-house procedure vs contempt of court: Contempt punishes anyone, including a judge, who disrespects or disobeys a court. The in-house procedure examines a judge's own conduct as a judge.
- Restatement of Values of Judicial Life vs in-house procedure: The Restatement (1997) is the code of conduct: what judges should and should not do. The in-house procedure is the method to act when a judge breaks it.
Issues, criticism and the way forward
- Secrecy: Complaints, inquiries and reports are usually kept confidential. Critics say this hides wrongdoing from the public. Supporters say confidentiality protects judges from false complaints meant to pressure them.
- No teeth: The procedure cannot punish or remove a judge. If the judge refuses to resign, the matter depends on Parliament, which has never removed a higher court judge.
- Judges judging judges: Since only judges run the process, some argue it cannot be fully independent or fair to complainants.
- No procedure for the CJI: There is no separate provision for a complaint against the Chief Justice of India.
- The failed law: The Judicial Standards and Accountability Bill, 2010 tried to create a statutory system with an oversight council, a code of conduct and minor penalties like warnings. It was passed by the Lok Sabha in 2012 but lapsed when the 15th Lok Sabha was dissolved in 2014.
- Way forward: Suggestions include a law that sets out graded penalties short of removal (such as warnings, withdrawal of work for a fixed period, or censure), a permanent body to receive complaints, time limits for inquiries, and clear rules on what can be made public, while still keeping judges safe from pressure by the government.
Concepts to Know
- Full Court: A meeting of all the judges of a court. Decisions taken there are about the running of the court, not about deciding cases.
- Higher judiciary: The Supreme Court and the High Courts. Their judges are appointed by the President and can be removed only by Parliament.
- Removal motion (often called impeachment): A formal proposal in Parliament to remove a judge for "proved misbehaviour or incapacity". It needs a special majority in both Houses.
- Voluntary retirement: When a person chooses to leave the job before the normal retirement age.
- Statutory: Created by a law passed by a legislature, as opposed to being created by a court resolution or a custom.
- Suggested by: C. Ravichandran Iyer v. Justice A.M. Bhattacharjee (1995).
- Restatement of Values of Judicial Life and the in-house resolution: Full Court, May 7, 1997.
- In-house procedure adopted: Full Court, December 15, 1999; made public in 2014.
- Committee for a High Court judge: 2 Chief Justices of other High Courts + 1 High Court judge. For a High Court Chief Justice: 1 Supreme Court judge + 2 High Court Chief Justices. For a Supreme Court judge: 3 Supreme Court judges.
- Strongest outcome: advice to resign; if refused, work withdrawn and report sent to the President and the Prime Minister.
- Yashwant Varma v. Union of India (August 7, 2025): procedure upheld; it is fact-finding, not removal.
- Judicial Standards and Accountability Bill, 2010: passed by the Lok Sabha in 2012; lapsed in 2014.
- No procedure for complaints against the CJI.
● Tracked since April 15, 2026 · last seen November 14, 2026 · updates as the daily brief publishes