← Resources · November 20, 2026
Polity & Governance GS2 6 min read

Election Commissioners' Appointment Case: Supreme Court Sends Recall Plea Against Split Verdict to the Constitution Bench

What happened
01

The case is about the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023. Petitioners say the law is unconstitutional because it removed the Chief Justice of India (CJI) from the panel that selects the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs).

02

On 23 September 2026, a two-judge Bench (Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma) gave a split verdict on whether the challenge should go to a larger Bench. Justice Datta felt it could be decided using settled principles. Justice Sharma felt it raised substantial constitutional questions needing a five-judge Constitution Bench. Both agreed to send the papers to the CJI so that a Constitution Bench could be formed directly.

03

The petitioners then filed an application asking the Court to recall (withdraw) the split verdict. Their ground was a conflict of interest: Justice Sharma's son is a standing counsel for the Election Commission of India before the Madhya Pradesh High Court. They asked that it be heard separately before the same two judges, since Justice Sharma was due to retire shortly.

04

On 20 November 2026, a Bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana declined a separate urgent hearing. It said the recall application, and any challenge to the reference itself, could be taken up by the five-judge Constitution Bench already set up for the case.

05

The CJI said this Bench could consider the recall application even after one of the judges who gave the split verdict retires. He also noted that Justice Datta, too, had independently said the matter needed a Constitution Bench.

Static topic 1 of 3 · Polity & Governance

Appointment and Removal of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners

The Election Commission of India runs elections to Parliament, state assemblies and the offices of President and Vice-President. It is led by a Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and, at present, two Election Commissioners (ECs). Article 324(2) says the President appoints them, subject to any law made by Parliament. For decades there was no such law, so the government in practice chose them. In 2023, both the Supreme Court and Parliament changed this, and the 2023 law is now being challenged.

Connection to this news

The core question before the Court is whether the 2023 Act's three-member panel, in which the government side has two of three votes, keeps the Election Commission independent enough. The split verdict and the recall plea are steps on the way to that main hearing before a Constitution Bench.

Static topic 2 of 3 · Polity & Governance

Constitution Benches and Article 145(3)

A Constitution Bench is a bench of at least five judges of the Supreme Court. Article 145(3) says that any case involving a substantial question of law about the interpretation of the Constitution must be heard by at least five judges. Most Supreme Court cases are heard by two or three judges, so big constitutional questions are sent up to a larger bench. Who sits on which bench is decided by the Chief Justice of India.

Connection to this news

The split verdict of 23 September 2026 is what moved the Election Commissioners' case to a five-judge Constitution Bench. The Court has now said that this larger Bench can also decide whether the split verdict itself should be recalled.

Static topic 3 of 3 · Polity & Governance

Judicial Recusal: The Rule Against Bias (Nemo Judex in Causa Sua)

Recusal means a judge stepping away from hearing a case because there is a risk, or a reasonable fear, that the judge may not be neutral. It comes from the old rule of natural justice nemo judex in causa sua: "no one should be a judge in their own cause". In India, no law lists when a judge must recuse; the decision is usually left to the judge, guided by court rulings and a judges' code of conduct. When a party claims that a judge should have recused, it may ask the court to recall (withdraw) the order that judge passed.

Connection to this news

The petitioners argue that because Justice Sharma's son is a standing counsel for the Election Commission, the split verdict should be recalled. The Court has not decided this claim yet; it has only said that the five-judge Constitution Bench can take it up, even after Justice Sharma retires.

Key facts & data
  • Law under challenge: CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
  • Selection Committee under the Act: Prime Minister, Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha, a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM (CJI excluded)
  • Anoop Baranwal judgment: 2 March 2023, five-judge Bench (panel of PM, LoP, CJI until a law is made)
  • Split verdict: 23 September 2026, Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma
  • Recall plea ruling: 20 November 2026, Bench of CJI Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana
  • Article 324(2): President appoints CEC and ECs, subject to law made by Parliament; Article 324(5): CEC removed like a Supreme Court judge
  • Article 145(3): at least five judges for substantial questions of constitutional interpretation
Read it? Now lock it in. The quiz for this day’s brief covers this story.
Take the quiz