Supreme Court Quashes Land Acquisition for Mining in Odisha's Scheduled Area: Gram Sabha Consent Is Mandatory
The Supreme Court set aside the Odisha government's acquisition of land for limestone mining by Dalmia Cement (Bharat) Limited in Sundargarh district, a tribal district that falls under the Fifth Schedule of the Constitution.
The case was Bibol Toppo v. State of Odisha and others, decided by a bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma. The petitioners were residents of Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna villages.
The company held a mining lease over 893.55 hectares (extended until February 2040) and wanted 273.57 hectares in the three villages acquired to get the surface rights needed for mining.
The Court held that under Section 41 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (LARR Act), land in a Scheduled Area cannot be acquired without the prior consent of the Gram Sabha.
It also held that this was acquisition for a private company for a public purpose, so the prior consent of at least 80% of affected families was needed, and that this consent must be taken along with the Social Impact Assessment (SIA), not collected bit by bit later.
The Orissa High Court had earlier upheld the acquisition, saying consent was not needed because the State was acquiring the land, and that consents given by 535 affected persons were enough. The Supreme Court reversed this. The ruling is seen as building on the 2013 Niyamgiri judgment, which made the Gram Sabha's decision central in tribal areas.
Fifth Schedule: Administration of Scheduled Areas
The Fifth Schedule is a part of the Indian Constitution that gives special protection to areas where tribal people live in large numbers. These areas are called Scheduled Areas. The Fifth Schedule gives the Governor of the state special powers to protect tribal land, stop exploitation by moneylenders, and adjust laws to suit tribal life. It applies to every state except Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram, whose tribal areas come under the Sixth Schedule instead.
Sundargarh is a fully Scheduled Area district of Odisha, which is why Section 41 of the LARR Act, built on the Fifth Schedule's idea of protecting tribal land, applied. The Supreme Court ruled that the Gram Sabha's prior consent was mandatory there, and quashed the acquisition because it had not been obtained in the manner the law requires.
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (LARR) Act, 2013
The LARR Act, 2013 is the main central law that tells the government how it can take private land for public projects, how much compensation owners must get, and how displaced families must be rehabilitated and resettled. It replaced the colonial Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and came into force on 1 January 2014. It added a Social Impact Assessment (SIA) and, for some projects, the consent of affected families.
The Supreme Court read Sections 2(2) and 41 together: since the land was being acquired for a private company in a Scheduled Area, both the Gram Sabha's prior consent and the consent of at least 80% of affected families, taken along with the SIA, were mandatory. Because they were not obtained this way, the acquisition fell.
Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC)
Free, Prior and Informed Consent, or FPIC, is the idea that indigenous and tribal communities have the right to say "yes" or "no" to a project that affects their land, forests, water or way of life. Free means without pressure, prior means before the project is approved, informed means with full and honest information, and consent means they can refuse. India does not use the term FPIC in its laws, but laws like PESA, the Forest Rights Act and the LARR Act carry the same idea through the Gram Sabha.
By holding that prior Gram Sabha consent is mandatory and must be taken at the right stage, the Supreme Court has strengthened the "prior" and "consent" parts of this idea. Activists see the ruling as following the path set by the Niyamgiri judgment of 2013.
- Case: Bibol Toppo v. State of Odisha and others; bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma
- Location: Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna villages, Sundargarh district, Odisha (Fifth Schedule area)
- Company: Dalmia Cement (Bharat) Limited, limestone mining; mining lease of 893.55 ha, extended until February 2040
- Land sought for acquisition: 273.57 ha (for surface rights)
- Legal basis: Section 41 (Gram Sabha prior consent in Scheduled Areas) and Section 2(2)(b)(i) (80% consent of affected families for private companies) of the LARR Act, 2013
- Consent must be taken along with the Social Impact Assessment
- Orissa High Court had upheld the acquisition, accepting consent of 535 affected persons in Form J
- Fifth Schedule: Article 244(1); TAC of up to 20 members (about three-fourths ST MLAs); Scheduled Areas in 10 states
- PESA Act, 1996: Section 4(i) Gram Sabha consultation before land acquisition
- Niyamgiri judgment: 18 April 2013; Samatha judgment: 1997