India Votes Against the UN Resolution on a Death Penalty Moratorium: The Debate Over a Fallible System
India voted against a draft resolution in the UN General Assembly's Third Committee (which deals with social, humanitarian and human rights matters) that calls on countries to stop executions for now (a moratorium) with a view to ending the death penalty. The document number was A/C.3/81/L.43.
The draft, led by Switzerland and Mexico, was approved on 13 November 2026 by 133 votes in favour, 33 against and 16 abstentions. It now goes to the full General Assembly. Such resolutions are not legally binding.
India said there is no international agreement against the death penalty and that each country has the sovereign right to decide its own laws. Its vote matches its stand in earlier sessions, including 2016, 2018 and 2024.
India also objected to one paragraph of a separate resolution on extrajudicial killings, which relied on a UN Special Rapporteur's view that the death penalty is in itself a form of torture. India supported that resolution overall.
A recent editorial argued that a punishment that cannot be undone needs an almost error-free justice system. Data back the concern: in 2025 the Supreme Court acquitted the accused in 10 of the 19 death penalty cases it decided and confirmed no death sentence for the third year in a row, while trial courts gave 128 death sentences.
At the end of 2025, 574 prisoners were on death row in India, according to a yearly study by the Square Circle Clinic at NALSAR University of Law (earlier known as Project 39A).
The "Rarest of Rare" Doctrine: Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980)
The "rarest of rare" doctrine is the rule that decides when an Indian court may give the death penalty. It says life imprisonment is the normal punishment for murder, and death can be given only in the rarest of rare cases, when the other option is "unquestionably foreclosed" (clearly ruled out). The Supreme Court laid down this rule in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980). Before choosing death, the judge must weigh the facts of the crime and the life and circumstances of the accused.
The doctrine was meant to keep the death penalty very rare. But trial courts still give over a hundred death sentences a year, while the Supreme Court often acquits or reduces them. This gap is the main reason critics question India's vote against the moratorium.
Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPR: Abolishing the Death Penalty
The Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) is the only worldwide treaty whose main aim is ending the death penalty. Countries that join it promise not to execute anyone and to take steps to abolish the death penalty in their law. It is "optional" because a country can be a party to the ICCPR without joining this protocol. The UN moratorium resolutions are a softer, non-binding step in the same direction.
The moratorium resolution asks countries to pause executions while thinking about abolition, without forcing them to sign the Protocol. India's no vote shows it wants to keep the death penalty as a legal option, even though it has carried out very few executions in recent decades (the last were in March 2020).
Constitutional Pardoning Powers: Articles 72 and 161
The pardoning power is the power of the President (under Article 72) and the Governor of a state (under Article 161) to forgive or reduce a punishment given by a court. It is a final safety net in case the courts have made a mistake or a punishment is too harsh. For a person sentenced to death, a mercy petition to the President is often the last hope. The President acts on the advice of the Union Council of Ministers.
Supporters of the death penalty point to mercy petitions as a safeguard against error. Critics reply that pardon is an executive decision, not a fresh look at evidence, so it cannot fully fix wrong convictions. This is part of the editorial's argument that only a near-infallible system can justify an irreversible punishment.
- UN draft resolution: A/C.3/81/L.43 (moratorium on the use of the death penalty), Third Committee, 81st session
- Vote on 13 November 2026: 133 in favour, 33 against, 16 abstentions; led by Switzerland and Mexico
- India voted against, citing lack of international consensus and sovereign right; same stand in 2016, 2018 and 2024
- Death row in India at end of 2025: 574 prisoners (highest since 2016)
- Trial courts gave 128 death sentences in 2025; the Supreme Court confirmed none (third straight year) and acquitted in 10 of 19 cases
- First UNGA moratorium resolution: 2007 (62/149)
- Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980): "rarest of rare" doctrine
- Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPR: 1989; India not a party